Charmant 5BR Bay Front Beach Cottage à Fair Harbour 33% Rate REMISE !!!

Thank you , Mary , for your 5 star review and wonderful comments. Our concierge team are always jazzed when our guests get the Fair Harbor and our beach cottage vibe, and enjoy their stay as much as we do!

Thank you, J, for your glowing review. I am always jazzed when my guests enjoy their stay, get the Fair Harbor vibe, and love the 100 year old beach cottage.

It was a pleasure hosting Jonathan, especially enjoying his reaction to his first visit to Fair Harbor and Fire Island.

Thank you, Patricia, for your glowing 5 star review. I am always jazzed when my guests enjoy Fair Harbor and our beach cottage as much as my family and I do.

Thank you, James. Phy and I enjoy hosting you every year and are thrilled that you all are hooked on the Fair Harbor vibe, and that you take care of our wonderful cottage like it is your own - which in a way, it is! See you next year!

Thank you, Tracy, for taking care of our cottage. I am so pleased that you enjoyed Fair Harbor and our cottage. You ware selcome back any time

Thank you, Stephen, for your glowing review and for you and your family being the best guests a host could have. I am always jazzed when guests treasure and fall in love with the Beach Cottage and Fair Harbor’s magical vibe as we do!

Thank you, Julianne, for your heartfelt review! So happy y’all enjoyed it and get the Cottage vibe. It was fun hanging and getting to know you and your family.

Always happy to have guests like Julianne and family - they embrace the Fair Harbor vibe, appreciate the cottage location and charm, and enjoy the beautiful, natural, laid-back bay and ocean beach scene.

We enjoyed hosting Michele and family, as they all were gracious, friendly and cared for our cottage.

Thank you, Kristin. It was a pleasure meeting and hosting you and your girlfriends. Y'all are welcome back any time.

Thank you, Mike, for your wonderful review, for being communicative and for taking great care of our cottage. Mike, family and friends were great guests. You all are welcome back any time!

I am appalled and outraged by Sarah’s review, as it is FILLED WITH FALSEHOODS, FALSE AND MISLEADING STATEMENTS! • I reject Sarah’s false statement that our cottage had unsafe and unsanitary conditions. If it were true, any guest, and especially someone with Sarah’s personality, would have notified me immediately, or at some point during their stay. • I was certainly misled by the Sarah and her family, as I had several conversations and texts with Sarah and her parents throughout her stay, and I received positive feedback about enjoying their stay. In fact, Sarah emailed me saying, “You are a fabulous host, thank you!!” • With the exception of the running toilet problem- which we subsequently replaced with a new Toto toilet, Sarah and her family NEVER mentioned a word to me about any of the issues she described during her entire 8 day/7 night stay. • Sarah’s statement about the house being unsafe is a falsehood. The cottage is safe and child-friendly. Please see past, current and future reviews to confirm that. As I told Sarah and family, and all of my guests, the east side of the house is not accessible and safely locked and blocked off from guest use, as there are construction materials there. • Sarah made a misleading statement about “dirty, very old used food”. We only leave condiments in the fridge, spices and coffee, as a courtesy & convenience to our guests. So the only “used” foods were spices and condiments like ketchup and mustard. • Sarah also made a misleading statement when she said, “almost all bikes are broken”. We have between 4 to 8 working bikes available for guests. • Sarah outright lied about the broken wagon. Her brother told me he broke the wagon wheel, while a child was riding in it (which is due to the excess weight pressure). The amazing thing is I fixed it the next day by replacing the wheel with a spare one! • Sarah also made a false statement when she wrote: “It’s more like a 3 bedroom with 2 attached sitting rooms”. Our cottage has 5 bedrooms, with pocket doors separating each of the two bedroom layouts on either side of the second floor – 2 bedrooms have two twin beds each, 1 bedroom has a double bed, 1 bedroom has a double and a twin bed, and the downstairs bedroom has a queen bed. • Finally, Sarah made a false statement when she wrote: “The closets are packed with owners belongings”. The closets have guest towels, house supplies (light bulbs, ironing board, vacuum, etc), first aid kit, etc. for guests’ convenience. We even have a Pack and Play and child gate for young children, which Sarah utilized and loved!!! In summary, Our cottage is almost 100 years old, so, yes it is rustic with a standard cottage style staircase, which makes it wonderfully charming and casual - in a Tennessee Williams novel kind-of-way. Fair Harbor and I take pride in our town’s and my cottage’s chill, laid-back vibe. If you want pristine, shiny new and immaculate, IT’S BEST TO GO TO THE HAMPTONS. IN CLOSING, SARAH'S REVIEW IS AN ABERRATION, AN ANOMALY. THIS IS PROVEN BY MY PAST, PRESENT AND FUTURE GUEST REVIEWS!

David and his friends were great guests. I am happy they enjoyed their stay and celebration.

Katie and her family and friends were great guests. We apologize for the BBQ, as things rust quickly on Fire Island, and we were not aware of the one burner malfunction. We replaced it with a new BBQ burner. Thank you!

Thanks, Michael. Great to host you and your family, and happy you all enjoyed it. Thanks for caring for the cottage.

Amos and family and friends were excellent guests - very friendly, communicative, and appreciative. Welcome back any time!

So thrilled Corrie and family enjoyed their stay. They are wonderful people and guests. They are welcome back any time.

Karen and family/friends were great and fun guests. We all had a good time together the day of arrival. They left the cottage in great shape, and took care of it like it was there own. They are welcome back any time.