We recently spent one night in the "Barn" before moving to the Farmhouse. (See all the Rental listings for this owner to see the Farmhouse). I really loved the barn it was sort of done in a loft modern style combining old and new in a wonderful way (Pottery Barn-ish). The upstairs was basically an awesome 1 Bed loft apartment with access (thru a bedroom) to a large deck. It had a flat screen TV and plenty of seating in the living area for a big group.

For us (3 couples) the layout and bed configuration just did not work. It had one bedroom with twin beds and that bedroom did not have direct access to a bathroom, you had to go through another bedroom. So a little odd at night if you needed to use the restroom. Additionally the Farmhouse had a pool and hot tub which we loved.

Given all that the Farmhouse would be my first choice (3 bed / 3 bath) but for 2 couples (who don't need a pool / hot tub) the Barn was lovely and I would recommend it for a stay.