I just spent 4 nights at the house with my 11-yo daughter and it was amazing.
The house is very comfortable, very clean and has everything you may need. We enjoyed the old, a-little-quirky house feel, but also appreciated the beautifully renovated, spacious bathrooms. Property manager was super prompt and helpful!
There's a neighbor house much closer than the description would indicate, but it was OK, especially since the house is at the end of the road.
The setting is gorgeous. The deck overlooking the creek is so pleasant and the swimming hole / waterfall was all that we had hoped for! We had plans to visit the Kaaterskill Falls (which was awesome by the way, just go early before it gets too crowded) and then just wanted to relax with easy access to swimming, and that was perfect. My daughter had a blast. (Full disclosure, the swimming hole is not completely private, neighbors from across the creek have access as well).
We chose to keep it low key this time, but the location would have been perfect if we wanted to explore more, with the 10-minute drive to any of the three towns and clearly endless trail / nature options.
It was just the two of us this time, but for a house that sleeps 5 with direct access to semi-private swimming, this is a really great deal.