The property itself is beautiful. It has a huge yard and the pool is wonderful. Also, the location can't be beaten. You are close to the beach, Watermill, Bridgehampton and Southhampton.
The house is another story. The listing says that it has 2 full bathrooms and a half bath. This is not the case. The master bathroom is in the middle of the room, open to the bedroom. There is a divider in front of the toilet, but if you like privacy while on the toilet - this isn't for you.
The second bathroom didn't have a functioning shower. The water was either scalding hot or freezing cold (with two kids this is not ideal). The owner called a plumber, but short of replacing the entire shower, it was not fixable. This bathroom also had grasscloth on the floor complete with unidentified stains and had not been remodeled for at least 30 years. Because this shower wasn't functional we ALL had to shower in the "master" shower in the middle of the bedroom.
The house also has a lot of bugs. I understand we are in the country, but there were tons of flying beetles as well as baby grasshoppers all over the house. We asked the owner to call an exterminator but he couldn't get anyone to come until a few days before we left and at that point, it was too late.
If you need functional bathrooms, this is not the house for you. I gave it three stars only because of the pool, yard, and location. The house itself is definitely more like 2 stars.