We had a great relaxing and quiet vacation with great views and daily visits by dolphins, turtles and resident iguanas. Great place to get away from it all.
The island is an almost indescribable experience. It is beautiful, clean, well stocked and the 360 degree views are amazing. I simply cannot speak highly enough of our time there.
Amazing location! Love the seclusion yet so close to everything we needed. Went to shore everyday for bait, groceriesâŠ. And we were back to the property in 30 minutes! The fishing was fantastic! Property was comfortable and had what we needed to have an amazing time! We will be back!
My husband and I stayed on the island for a week. We gad tge greatest vacation we have ever had. Indescribable experience surrounded by the ocean. Thank you Wesley for being such a great host.
We plan to return often!!
My new wife and I rented the island for our honeymoon. The owner was always very quick and responsive to all our questions. We had a great time and it's a perfect get away for boating, kayaking, swimming, fishing, snorkeling, and catching lobster all around the island. I highly recommend bringing snorkel gear as you'll have a blast inside and outside the rocks surrounding the island. If you like fishing or just want to see a show, when it gets dark, go sit on the dock on the far right, and you will see a huge school of tarpon feasting on the live bait in the water. I caught a nice size snapper in the middle of the night along with bonnet head sharks. Bring your own poles and bait. They have a net with tickle sticks to catch the lobster as well. Highly recommend!! Your privacy may get a little invaded on the outskirts of the rocks at times. Several times a boat would pull up and anchor right outside the rocks and snorkel for lobster. The pool was great and we loved all the sea life and little crabs on the island. We tried to be careful not to step on them. There's even an iguana running around the island. When we arrived it was very late and dark out. We knew it was a boat ride to the island, we just didn't know we'd need to navigate the boat by ourselves. Luckily I had a small amount of experience driving a boat, but not on the ocean with shallow spots at night. We were shown how to get to the island, how to drive the boat, and helped back to the dock were we started. No lights on the boat. Just given a flashlight. We were given a quick tour of the island and instructions for the generator which will be required for A/C if you desire at $6 per hour. They had 3 fans in the house and we used them all in the Master Bedroom which seemed to be the warmest room in the house even with all the doors wide open. We had a little issue after leaving the island with the A/C bill as we are positive we used the A/C for only 16 hours however, we were billed for much more. The owner assured us the generator tracks this accurately, however something was not right and the owner worked with us to make it right. Ask the owner about Chef Flavor if you'd like someone to come cook a meal for you! Highly recommended! Con's: no dishwasher; trash must be transported by you back to shore; one roll of paper towels(bring your own); jets on pool only available 1100 - 1400, several ceiling fans were not working in the house and need to be fixed.
East Sister Rock was nothing short of incredible. Beautiful views with constant sea breezes. Being able to completely disconnect and unwind we were able to achieve full relaxation! We cannot wait to come back with our family and share the beauty of this slice of paradise. Wesley was fantastic about communicating and was so welcoming. Thank you for sharing your home.
This property was nothing short of amazing! My wife and I had dreamed of doing a trip like this since weâve been married, due to the season we were in when we tied the knot a honeymoon just wasnât in the cards. 9 years later we arrived on East Sister Rock, and enjoyed this incredible home with our family. The home was well kept, the bathrooms were gorgeous, and the home is nothing short of captivating. Wesley was always immediately responsive if we had any questions, and we are so grateful Elena, and Bob allowed us to share their piece of paradise!
All amenities and pictures are accurate. Owner/operators friendly and very responsive to texts or calls. Experience is priceless. Did one excursion with 2 conch fishing charter for yellowfin and permit fish, highly recommend they pick up at the dock. The inner lagoon provides all kinds of wildlife: baby nurse sharks, eel, barracuda, parrot fish, sting ray etc. even saw Dolphins close to island feeding.
We ran the generator for AC after 9pm til around 4am and always slept comfortably however this is really not needed as the 360° ocean allows for an amazing breeze. Beds were comfortable. If you are picky about softness of toilet paper or laundry detergent brand bring your own even though they provide. Sugar ants in the kitchen/house were difficult to manage, wish I had brought a product called Terro (buy on Amazon). Donât let these suggestions deter you as we will book this island again. Oh ya, sign in to the Jenga game.
We had a wonderful time at the island. Lots of room for two couples. We enjoyed the wrap around porch. You could always find the perfect place to sit and enjoy the ocean. We loved watching the sun rises and sun sets! We loved snorkeling around the island, lots of fish. Very relaxing place!
Excellent vacation location. The island was beautiful and the owners vey responsive.
We all had an amazing time on the island. It was beautiful. The whole experience was great from start to finish. An absolutely fantastic place to vacation.
We never got tired of the view, the sound of the ocean, the ocean breeze. Bathrooms are updated since the listing pictures.
The pool table, dart board, and hammocks were a hit for the whole family.
We already are checking calendars to rebook!
Thank you!
This place is so beautiful from the moment you arrive you will be so relaxed. The water is crystal blue and you can see the bottom. Lots of fish, sting rays, sharks. We had a great time thank you.
The island was everything you could hope for! The house was clean, plenty of necessities were provided, communication with the owner was always on point and recommendations were given. It was a great experience and worth every penny!
We had an amazing time while isolated on our own island. We brought everything we needed but was extremely close to shore and stores if we needed anything. We brought our own boat so we could fish and play. Nice place and a good time was had by all!
Spent a week here with two other couples. It was amazing! Pool was great. Fishing was fun. Caught a 3' tarpon, baracuda and numerous other fish. It was windy and the ocean was very choppy so we weren't able to dive. But for some reason it didnt really matter..when your spending a week in paradise it doesnt seem to matter..I dont think I've ever had a more relaxing vacation. Thank you Wesley for everything!
Henry and Debbie
Roger and Kathy
Rick and Bobbie
đ
Nestled in the crystal-clear waters of the Florida Keys, East Sister Rock Island is an extraordinary private island retreat that embodies the essence of tropical seclusion and natural beauty. Just a short boat ride from Marathon, this exclusive paradise offers a rare opportunity to experience the unspoiled charm of the Keys in a setting unlike any other.
East Sister Rock Island is a natural conch breeding ground. (IT IS ILLEGAL to touch the conch!)
Surrounded by panoramic ocean views, the islandâs stunning solar-powered home is a masterpiece of sustainable luxury, designed to harmonize with its pristine environment while offering modern comforts. Expansive wraparound decks invite guests to savor breathtaking sunrises and sunsets over the turquoise waters, while the gentle sound of waves creates a tranquil escape from the everyday.
What truly sets East Sister Rock Island apart is its sense of total privacy and serenity.
Here, you are immersed in the beauty of natureâsnorkeling through vibrant coral reefs just offshore, fishing in world-class waters, or simply relaxing as tropical breezes whisper through the palms. Itâs a place where the pace of life slows, allowing you to reconnect with the rhythms of the sea and sky.
Whether seeking a peaceful retreat, an unforgettable adventure, or a once-in-a-lifetime gathering with loved ones, East Sister Rock Island offers an unparalleled experienceâwhere luxury meets nature in perfect harmony.