Charming Settlers Cottage

My sister Linda and I began our journey as hosts in Park City, Utah, back in 2003. We started by purchasing and remodeling several condos, which we initially handed over to property managers. As the short-term rental market grew, especially with platforms like VRBO, we decided to take on managing them ourselves.

By 2015, we sold our eight properties in Park City and chose to start again, this time closer to home in Pine Valley, Utah. With the help of my husband, Kendall, we take great pride in personally caring for each of our properties. We love creating spaces where guests can feel at home, and we’re proud of the unique experiences our homes offer.

We chose Pine Valley because it holds a special place in our hearts, filled with family memories. Our parents owned property here, and my sister Linda still owns the Petersen Cottage. When we decided to leave Park City, we knew that Pine Valley, with its rich history and serene beauty, was the perfect place to settle. It’s truly a hidden gem, a little slice of heaven that we wanted to share with our guests, so they can experience the peace and charm of this unique town.

Settlers Cottage is truly unique because it retains its original brick structure from one of the early settlers of the area. Each room tells the story of a different time and owner, creating a one-of-a-kind blend of history and charm. The bedroom was originally a shed, rolled in on logs, which explains the unusual width of the wall next to the house. The kitchen, built in the 1940s or 50s, predates modern conveniences like electricity and plumbing. The bathroom wasn’t added until the 1970s.

When we purchased the property, we updated it with all the modern essentials, including electrical systems, plumbing, windows, and doors. Although many suggested we tear it down, preserving its history was important to us. Our guests now get to experience the perfect mix of old and new—the yin and yang of different generations. In a world of instant gratification, a stay here offers the chance to step back in time and enjoy a simpler way of living, even if just for a short while.