The house is fine and at a great location. The island was beautiful and quiet while we were there. Beach and sound access are both just down the road and since it's at the end of the island there's lot of beach to explore, well within walking distance.
That said, the place was a bit barebones and we felt at times like we were nickeled-and-dimed. They don't provide any linens, which wasn't indicated on the Vrbo description when we booking. That includes not just bedsheets and towels, etc but also bathmats, kitchen towels, etc. You can rent them separately if you like. We opted to bring our own, though that accounted for most of our luggage and it felt a bit silly.
They also provided only 2 rolls of toilet paper for 3 bathrooms and no soap anywhere. Not terrible, but again felt like we were getting nickeled-and-dimed.